Book Review: The Emergence of Lincoln, Volume II: Prologue to Civil War, 1859-61 by Allan Nevins

The Emergence of Lincoln: Prologue to Civil War, 1859-61 by Allan Nevins
My rating: 4 of 5 stars

While 1859 seemed to be an uneasy year, there was hope that the moderates and conservatives in both North and the South had marginalized the radicals in both sections then one man’s fanaticism started the chain reaction in the South which changed the nation’s course. The Emergence of Lincoln, Volume II: Prologue to Civil War, 1859-61 is the fourth book of Allan Nevin’s Ordeal of the Union series as John Brown’s raid exasperates tensions as advocates for a Southern Confederacy whip up their faux-nationalism while Republicans aimed to nominate a moderate to ensure their victory in 1860 with no on realizing for once the South would actually walk the talk they’ve been saying for over a decade.

Through 489 pages of text and four appendices, Nevins covers the final dramatic movements as the national fabric was torn in two from John Brown’s raid, the breaking up of the Democratic Party in Charleston and Baltimore, the election of Lincoln followed by Buchanan’s month-long dithering before committing to the Union even as secessionists created a Confederacy. Nevins’ research and writing continue to be top notch, but the best part of the book was Nevin’s analysis of what led to the Civil War from page 462 to 471. Nevin’s conclusion on page 468 was simple, “The main root of the conflict (and there were minor roots) was the problem of slavery with its complementary problem of race-adjustment [emphasis Nevins],” the latter part of that quote is something that Nevins had been developing and in concluding this volume set the stage both for the upcoming war that he was to chronicle as well as the reconstruction of the nation that he planned to cover but never did. Being the final volume of Nevins’ chronicle of the lead-up to the American Civil War, the blow-by-blow account of how a nation victorious in a war that increased its size by a third staggered towards breaking apart while showing how various regions of that country changed economically and in viewing itself within the nation.

The Emergence of Lincoln, Volume II: Prologue to Civil War, 1859-61 culminates Allan Nevins’ excellent relating of the decade plus of American history from the end of the Mexican War to the verge of the Civil War.

View all my reviews